Medical Expert Witness / Anaphylaxis and food allergy

Anaphylaxis and food allergy expert witness

I am a board certified allergist and immunologist. I review cases in which a person had anaphylaxis, or a reaction that may have been anaphylaxis, and the question is whether it was recognized and treated as the standard of care requires.

I review the full record and explain the medicine in plain language, the same way for either side.

What I review

Anaphylaxis and food allergy cases

  • Anaphylaxis recognition and treatment in any setting, from the allergy and immunology perspective
  • Timing of epinephrine and the role of antihistamines and steroids
  • Observation periods, discharge decisions and biphasic reactions
  • Prescription of epinephrine auto-injectors and discharge instructions
  • Food allergy diagnosis, testing, counseling and emergency action plans
  • The medical questions in school, camp, childcare and restaurant cases
  • Reactions during procedures, infusions and allergen immunotherapy
  • Insect sting reactions and referral for venom immunotherapy

Common questions

Questions these cases often raise

  • Did the presentation meet accepted criteria for anaphylaxis, and what treatment did it call for?
  • When was epinephrine given, and was the dose, route and site appropriate?
  • Was the observation period reasonable given the severity of the reaction?
  • Was the patient discharged with an epinephrine prescription, instructions and a referral?
  • Was the allergy documented and communicated so the next clinician would see it?

The published standards

What the guidelines say

The allergy specialty societies publish joint practice parameters on anaphylaxis. The most recent update, Anaphylaxis: A 2023 practice parameter update, appeared in December 2023. It is the most widely cited U.S. anaphylaxis guideline.

Epinephrine is first-line treatment for anaphylaxis, given promptly. Delayed epinephrine has been associated with worse outcomes. Antihistamines and steroids should not delay epinephrine.

The 2020 update advises observing patients after their symptoms resolve, with a longer period after a severe reaction or more than one dose of epinephrine. The 2023 update addresses when a patient treated at home needs emergency care.

Guidelines change. I apply the version in effect at the time of care, and I say which version that is.

Sources:

Questions from counsel

Frequently asked

Do you review cases for both sides? Yes. I accept plaintiff and defense engagements and apply the same analysis.

Do you review restaurant and school cases? Yes, on the medical questions: the diagnosis, the treatment, its timing and causation. I do not give opinions on food service or school operations.

Can you speak to causation? Yes, when my training and the record support an opinion. Some causation questions need another specialist, and I say so.

What do you need to start? A conflicts check first. Send the parties, the jurisdiction and the general allegation. Please do not send records, protected health information or privileged material with the first message.

Related

More on my expert witness work

Inquiries

Start with a conflicts check.

Include the case caption or party names, the jurisdiction, the specialty and general allegation, and your report and discovery deadlines. Please do not send records with the first message.

Inquiries are answered within two business days.

Direct email

drlaurenfine@gmail.com

Send an Inquiry

Fee schedule and an engagement letter are provided once the conflicts check clears. Based in the Weston and Fort Lauderdale area. Please do not send protected health information or privileged material before engagement.