Medical Expert Witness / Asthma

Asthma expert witness

I am a board certified allergist and immunologist. Asthma is a core part of my specialty. I review cases in which asthma was missed, undertreated, or poorly managed during an attack, and cases in which an exposure at work or at home is said to have caused or worsened it.

I look at the whole course: the diagnosis, the controller plan, the warning signs, and what happened in the hours before the outcome.

What I review

Asthma cases

  • Missed or delayed asthma diagnosis
  • Long-term control and escalation of treatment
  • Emergency and hospital management of acute exacerbations
  • Discharge planning after an exacerbation
  • Fatal and near-fatal asthma
  • Occupational asthma and workplace exposures
  • Environmental and indoor allergen exposures
  • School and childcare asthma action plans

Common questions

Questions these cases often raise

  • Was asthma recognized from the history and findings?
  • Was control assessed and treatment stepped up when it was poor?
  • Were warning signs of a severe attack recognized and acted on?
  • Was the patient discharged with a clear plan and follow-up?
  • Did the claimed exposure more likely than not cause or worsen the symptoms, given the timing and the evidence?

The published standards

The standards I apply

I apply the asthma guidelines in effect at the time of care, such as the NAEPP Expert Panel Report 3 (2007), its 2020 Focused Update, and the GINA reports, and I say which version applies. Standards change, and an opinion should hold the clinician to what was expected then, not now.

In exposure cases, I separate what is known about the allergen or irritant from what the record shows about this patient's timing, symptoms and testing. Exposure levels may need an industrial hygienist.

Questions from counsel

Frequently asked

Do you review indoor exposure claims? Yes, from the allergy and asthma side: whether the exposure more likely than not caused or worsened this person's symptoms, based on the timing, the testing and qualified exposure data.

Do you review cases for both sides? Yes. I accept plaintiff and defense engagements and apply the same analysis.

Do you review pediatric cases? Yes, for allergy and immunology care, which covers children and adults.

What do you need to start? A conflicts check first. Send the parties, the jurisdiction and the general allegation. Please do not send records, protected health information or privileged material with the first message.

Related

More on my expert witness work

Inquiries

Start with a conflicts check.

Include the case caption or party names, the jurisdiction, the specialty and general allegation, and your report and discovery deadlines. Please do not send records with the first message.

Inquiries are answered within two business days.

Direct email

drlaurenfine@gmail.com

Send an Inquiry

Fee schedule and an engagement letter are provided once the conflicts check clears. Based in the Weston and Fort Lauderdale area. Please do not send protected health information or privileged material before engagement.