Medical Expert Witness / Failure to diagnose and diagnostic error

Failure to diagnose and diagnostic error expert witness

I am the assistant dean responsible for clinical skills education at a U.S. medical school. My work is how medical students are taught to take a history, build a differential diagnosis and revise it.

I give standard of care opinions in allergy and immunology, including missed and delayed allergic and immunologic diagnoses. In other specialties, I address the diagnostic process alongside an expert in the defendant's field.

I review the record encounter by encounter and explain how the diagnostic process applies to what was known at each point, the same way for either side.

What I review

Diagnostic error cases

  • Missed and delayed diagnosis of allergic and immunologic conditions
  • The diagnostic reasoning process in missed and delayed diagnosis cases, within the limits of my training
  • Premature closure and anchoring, judged by what was known at that time
  • Follow-up of abnormal findings and results
  • Adequacy of the history and physical examination
  • Handoff, follow-up and communication
  • Supervision and assessment of medical students and residents

Common questions

Questions these cases often raise

  • What was known at each encounter?
  • Was the evaluation reasonable given what was known at the time?
  • Did a finding appear that called for a change in the plan?
  • Was there a plan to follow up, and did it happen?
  • Was there an error? If so, was it in the reasoning, the system, or both?

The published standards

How common diagnostic error is

The National Academies concluded in 2015 that most people will experience at least one diagnostic error in their lifetime.

The same report describes diagnosis as a team process that unfolds over time, and notes that a diagnostic error is not always due to one person's mistake. That distinction matters in many cases, and I address it directly.

Sources:

Questions from counsel

Frequently asked

Do you review cases outside allergy and immunology? On the diagnostic process only. Standard of care opinions for other specialties come from experts in those specialties. If a case needs an expert in the defendant's specialty, I will say so and help you find one.

Can you explain reasoning in plain language? I teach clinical reasoning. I explain how a diagnosis is made in plain language.

Do you review cases for both sides? Yes. I accept plaintiff and defense engagements and apply the same analysis.

What do you need to start? A conflicts check first. Send the parties, the jurisdiction and the general allegation. Please do not send records, protected health information or privileged material with the first message.

Related

More on my expert witness work

Inquiries

Start with a conflicts check.

Include the case caption or party names, the jurisdiction, the specialty and general allegation, and your report and discovery deadlines. Please do not send records with the first message.

Inquiries are answered within two business days.

Direct email

drlaurenfine@gmail.com

Send an Inquiry

Fee schedule and an engagement letter are provided once the conflicts check clears. Based in the Weston and Fort Lauderdale area. Please do not send protected health information or privileged material before engagement.