Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Nothing here is sponsored and no brand paid to be included.
Both brands are built around sensitive skin. They get there in different ways. Here is what each one leaves out, what each one claims, and how to choose.
The short answer
If your skin reacts to almost everything, start with Vanicream. The whole line leaves out a specific list of common irritants and allergens, and it costs less.
If your skin is sensitive but not raw, and you want fragrance-free makeup and more textures to choose from, Clinique gives you more range.
Side by side
| Clinique | Vanicream | |
|---|---|---|
| Fragrance | Says its skin care and makeup are 100% fragrance free. Its perfumes are the exception. | Says its products are free of fragrance and masking fragrance. |
| Also left out | No brand-wide list beyond fragrance | Dyes, lanolin, parabens and formaldehyde releasers |
| Testing claims | Allergy tested, with nearly 6 million test applications to date, and dermatologist tested | Dermatologist tested |
| Range | Full skin care and makeup line | Mostly skin care basics: cleansers, moisturizers, sunscreen and a few treatments |
| Other | Founded in 1968 with a dermatologist | Several products carry the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance |
| Price | Department-store pricing | Drugstore pricing |
Why Vanicream's list matters
Vanicream leaves out several of the ingredients sensitive skin most often avoids, all at once: fragrance, masking fragrance, dyes, lanolin, parabens and formaldehyde releasers. That makes it a simple place to start if your skin reacts to everything.
Why Clinique works for so many people
Clinique takes fragrance out of all its skin care and makeup, and it allergy tests its formulas. Fragrance is one of the most common causes of allergic skin reactions, so that alone helps a lot of sensitive skin.
Makeup is where Clinique has no real competition from Vanicream. Clinique sunscreen and mascara are my everyday pair. More on how Clinique tests is in is Clinique allergy tested?
Which should you choose?
- Your skin reacts to almost everything, or you have eczema: start with Vanicream.
- You know you react to a preservative: Vanicream, and read every ingredient list anyway.
- You want fragrance-free makeup: Clinique.
- Your skin is sensitive but calm, and you want more textures: Clinique.
- You can mix them. A Vanicream moisturizer under Clinique sunscreen or mascara works well. Add one new product at a time.
What about Origins?
Origins leans on plant extracts and essential oils in many of its products. Plant ingredients can be allergens too. If your skin is easily irritated, check each Origins ingredient list for fragrance and essential oils before you buy.
Where to start
Vanicream Facial Moisturizer SPF 30. Free of dyes, fragrance, masking fragrance, lanolin, parabens and formaldehyde releasers.
Clinique Moisture Surge 100H Auto-Replenishing Hydrator. A light gel-cream with hyaluronic acid and aloe. Fragrance free.
Clinique SPF 50 Mineral Sunscreen Fluid for Face. Mineral filters only, in a thin fluid. Fragrance free and allergy tested.
Clinique High Impact Mascara. Fragrance free and allergy tested. Eyelids are thin skin, so what you put near them matters.
See my full list of the best skin care for sensitive skin.
Make room
The brand matters less than the list. Choose fragrance free, keep your routine short, and add one thing at a time.
Need help with more than products? Your first coaching session is free, or start with a free 20-minute fit call.
- Is Clinique makeup good for sensitive skin?
- Does hypoallergenic mean allergy free?
- Is there hypoallergenic perfume?
- Dust mite allergy: the allergist's bedroom checklist
- Holiday allergies checklist
- Are hypoallergenic dogs real?
- Best Clinique products for sensitive skin
- Clinique Black Friday: what to buy
- Best fragrance-free laundry detergent
Frequently asked questions
Is Vanicream or Clinique better for sensitive skin?
For skin that reacts to almost everything, Vanicream is the simpler starting point because it leaves out a long list of common irritants and allergens. For sensitive but calm skin, or if you want fragrance-free makeup, Clinique offers more range.
Is Clinique hypoallergenic?
Clinique says its products are allergy tested and 100% fragrance free. Hypoallergenic has no federal definition in the US, so those two claims tell you more.
What is Vanicream free of?
Vanicream says its products are free of dyes, fragrance, masking fragrance, lanolin, parabens and formaldehyde releasers.
Is Clinique or Origins better for easily irritated skin?
For easily irritated skin, fragrance free usually matters most. Clinique skin care is fragrance free. Many Origins products include plant extracts or essential oils, so check each ingredient list.
Can I use Clinique and Vanicream together?
Yes. Many people pair a Vanicream cleanser or moisturizer with Clinique sunscreen or makeup. Add one new product at a time so you can tell what works.