An allergist’s answer
Real or artificial tree if you have allergies?
The tree you choose, and how you store it, matters in an allergy-friendly home.
Here is how a live tree and an artificial tree compare for allergies and asthma, and how to make either one easier on your family.
The live tree
Researchers at SUNY Upstate Medical University tested clippings from 28 live Christmas trees and found 53 different molds. Most were potential allergens. The same research cited an earlier study in which mold spores in a room with a live tree rose sharply over two weeks.
A warm living room is a good place for mold to grow. Sap can also irritate the skin. If you go live:
- Shake or blow it off outside before it comes in.
- Wear gloves and long sleeves to handle it.
- Keep it up for the shortest time you are happy with.
- Run a true HEPA air purifier in the same room.
The artificial tree
An artificial tree is not automatically allergy friendly. It spends eleven months in an attic, basement or garage, where it collects dust and, if the space is damp, mold.
- Clean it before it goes up, outside or in the garage.
- Vacuum it with a sealed HEPA vacuum, so the dust stays in the vacuum.
- Skip flocking if you are sensitive. It can shed as you decorate.
- Pack it away in a sealed plastic bin, not the original cardboard box.
- Keep storage dry. A dehumidifier keeps mold from moving in before next year.
The allergy-friendly tree
What I would buy
A plain tree, clean air, and a dry place to store it.
The Holiday Aisle
7.5' Pre-Lit Artificial Spruce
$199.99
A full tree, without flocking. Wipe it down before it goes up, and you skip the mold a live tree brings in.
Shop the tree
Shop nowRabbit Air
MinusA2 Air Purifier
Asthma and allergy friendly certified. Run it in the room with the tree.
Shop the purifier
Shop nowKenmore
Elite Pet Friendly Upright
A sealed HEPA system, so dander you vacuum up stays in the vacuum.
Shop the vacuumHoliday allergies
The tree is only one part
Boxes of decorations, scented candles, holiday food and staying with family all add up. The full checklist is printable.
See the holiday allergy checklistFrequently asked questions
Is a real or artificial Christmas tree better for allergies?
For most people with allergies or asthma, a clean artificial tree is the better choice. Live trees bring mold indoors. Artificial trees can collect dust and mold in storage, so clean them before they go up.
Can a real Christmas tree cause allergies?
Yes. Live trees carry mold, and spore levels in the room can rise the longer the tree stays up. Sap can also irritate the skin.
How do I clean an artificial Christmas tree for allergies?
Take it outside or into the garage, shake or blow off the dust, and wipe it down. Vacuum with a sealed HEPA vacuum. Store it in a sealed plastic bin, in a dry place.
Are flocked trees bad for allergies?
Flocking can shed as the tree is handled and decorated. If you are sensitive, choose a plain tree.
More from the allergist and the Sunday Letter: Holiday allergies checklist, Dust mite allergy, The allergy-friendly home, How to say no to hosting the holidays.
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Nothing here is sponsored and no brand paid to be included. Codes are shared with me by the brands. Prices were current when this page was written and may change. These are product picks, not medical or veterinary advice.